Meet Commodore Barney--You Won't Forget Him--And Shouldn't


“History is a fickle muse and fame her unfair offspring.”

                                                                                       ---Bernard Cornwell in The Fort

                                                -------------------------------

Return with me now to a blazingly hot and scary day 200 years ago. The date: 24 August   1814.

The Battle of Bladensburg occurred that day.

Much has been written about that battle on Bladensburg Road. And justly. It’s good for a nation to reflect on its blunders. And the battle was a blunder. “The greatest disgrace ever dealt to American arms,” one historian calls it.

 That’s because frightened American troops and militia ran from the British who had invaded our country and were marching toward Washington D.C. Our mostly terrified defenders allowed the enemy to burn the United States capitol. And in the captured White House, British officers ate at the dining room table of President James Madison.

The media regurgitated all that in recent bicentennial coverage of the War of 1812 between the United States and Briton. Yet the coverage almost entirely omitted one important fact:

American heroism didn’t die that August day. One unsung 55-year-old warrior and his men gave the shocked British a costly display of American courage.

  Strangely, historians of early America have typically slighted the remarkable story of one of our nation’s most loyal, fearlessness, and skillful patriots, a veteran of the American Revolution and the War of 1812. Thus he has been cheated. You have been too, if, as is likely, you haven’t heard his story.

 So listen.

His name is Barney--Commodore Joshua Barney.

 He was a Baltimore boy who learned seamanship on the Chesapeake Bay, and went to sea at the age of 12.  When he was 15 years old—yes 15—he took command of a foundering merchant ship and saved ship, crew, and cargo.

 By 18 Barney was battling the British in the American Revolution. He served as a commissioned naval officer and as a feared privateer sponsored by the colonies. He fought numerous sea battles, winning most of them. He was captured six times, tortured, and staged a couple of spectacular escapes.

 After the Revolutionary War, he commanded a French fleet and continued fighting the British. Then at the start of the War of 1812, when it was clear the paltry U. S. naval force couldn’t cope with the invading British fleet, he designed, built, and commanded a flotilla of small, oar-driven gunboats to badger and distract the raiders.

Then too, as the naval scholar Louis Arthur Norton writes:

Barney” made and lost several fortunes; won, lost, then regained the admiration of his countrymen; and through it all was true to his principles. Barney was not a typical naval officer of the era by any means; indeed, his career was far more interesting.”

Before the Bladensburg battle Barney based his flotilla of gunboats on the Patuxent River. The enemy knew it. And as a first step in assaulting Washington, British Admiral Sir George Cockburn sent a squadron of 23 ships and an infantry unit to attack Barney’s force from land and river.

 Realizing he was about to be attacked and surrounded, Barney marched 400 of his flotillamen to a defensive position at Upper Marlboro. He left 120 sailors behind to booby trap the flotilla boats. Which they did.

When the British rushed to confiscate the boats, they exploded with a blast that also destroyed 15 of 16 attacking enemy gun-boats. And in the confusion of smoke and falling debris, all of Barney’s men escaped, lugging five salvaged cannon with them. 

By now Barney knew British Major General Robert Ross was leading some 4,000 to 5,000 infantry toward Washington via Bladensburg village on Bladensburg Road. So he marched his sailors and cannon toward the inevitable fight.

Barney dutifully reported to commanding general, Brigadier William Winder, the politically appointed brother of Maryland’s governor. Gen. Winder ordered Barney and his small force away from the impending action, sending them off to guard a bridge.

 This is not at all what the frustrated Barney had in mind.

Luckily President James Madison was checking the troops and happened by in his carriage. Barney approached the President. He politely explained that it made sense to blow up the bridge and free his men to fight rather than have them idling on guard duty. Madison agreed, and countermanded Gen. Winder.

Barney then had his sailors and 78 Marines take up a position on a hill overlooking a valley and bridge the Redcoats were bound to cross.

Almost immediately the Redcoats charged. Barney’s men let loose a barrage of cannon and musket fire that swept the attackers from the road. The enemy rallied quickly and struck again. Barney’s men mowed them down. Again the British attacked only to fall like bowling pins.

Finally a large, remarkably brave British infantry column charged through the suffocating smoke and blazing fire. The attackers threatened to overrun the floatillamen. Seeing this, Barney ordered his 78 Marines to counter attack.

Historian Morton writes:

The “marine unit charged screaming down the hill, crossed an open field, and leapt over a stone wall topped by a wooden fence where the British had taken cover to catch a temporary breath in the intense summer heat. The Americans drove the weary regulars back into a ravine wounding many officers and men with musket fire and bayonet stabs.”

Barney’s outnumbered sailors and marines had repulsed some 600 of the king’s finest.

Now Barney looked for other American units to charge the stalled British invaders and force their likely retreat. He was astonished to see that he and his men were the only American fighters left on the battlefield. All others had run away, excepting two small Maryland militia detachments off to the right. Yet in front of him loomed an army of thousands that was readying to resume the attack.

As the British launched another assault, Barney rallied his men. He soon realized however that his force would be surrounded and overwhelmed. Ammunition was low. Victory was impossible.

 Still, Barney thought he might lead an escape, save his cannons, and renew the fight elsewhere. He mounted his horse to better lead his men, but a sharpshooter shot the animal. Barney scrambled to his feet, but the shooter took him down with a musket ball to the thigh.

Unable to move, bleeding heavily, and weak, Barney ordered all his men to leave the guns and retreat, including officers who were trying to rig a litter and carry him off the field. One officer, Lieutenant Jesse Huffington, refused that order and stayed by his suffering leader.

A witness to the battle that historian Norton refers to as “a British observer” wrote:

“With the exception of a party of sailors, from the gun boats [barges] under the command of Commodore Barney, no troops could have behaved worse…. Of the sailors, however, it would be injustice not to speak in the terms which their conduct merits. They were employed as gunners, and not only did they serve their guns with quickness and precision which astonished their assailants, but they stood till some of them were actually bayonetted, with fusees in their hands; nor was it till their leader was wounded, and they saw themselves deserted on all sides by the soldiers, that they quitted the field.” 

British soldiers quickly captured Barney and Huffington. But the captain of one of the enemy’s warships knew of Barney, ordered that he be treated gently, and had his ship’s surgeon dress the warrior’s wounds. When General Ross, the British commander, heard his new prisoner was the legendary Commodore Barney, he went to see him.

 The general told Barney that with just a handful of men he had given his troops a severe shock. He added, “I am very glad to see you Commodore.”

Replied Barney, “I am sorry I cannot return the compliment, General.”

The Battle of Bladensburg was Barney’s final battle. On December 1, 1818 the musket ball that could not be removed caused a thrombosis that took the old sailor’s life.

Barney had been courageous in hand to hand combat, a relentless leader in battle, and above all a true American patriot. Even his enemies considered him a hero.

 So give this old warrior his due. Remember him.

                                                                                      ------Gus Gribbin

Prof. Louis Norton’s scholarly and entertaining book Joshua Barney: Hero of the Revolution and 1812 vividly recounts Barney’s swashbuckling life. It is available from the Naval Institute Press, 291 Wood Road, Annapolis, MD 21402.
The pictures presented above are generic War of 1812 images and do not show Bladensburg action..